Tracking philosophies. With:
Phil’s Channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/philzeo
and Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/onewallstudio/
and Joshua Lopez
For the past few weeks, I have been relentlessly harassed and false copyright flagged by Universal Music Group whenever I do a Facebook livestream. These streams are educational videos record myself, in my studio of original music and are mostly drum recordings which I then show how to apply EQ and compression to, for example.
The stream is stopped, kicking off all the viewers and then I have to file a dispute to even get the video back, but the stream is ruined.
As a single example, you can check this video and see the matching content that they are laying claim to
Facebook has left me absolutely no way to contact support and plead my case for a whitelisting or some other solution. UMG has not responded to my emails, messages or phone calls.
On YouTube, AdRev, which turns out is also audiomicro.com has DMCA flagged me for a video which again, has none of their content and is all original content of mine. You can hear the “matching content” yourself
I have tried phone, email, filed a counter at YouTube and have found no way to truly contact any of the people responsible. I have sent more than enough messages in every way I could to AdRev, UMG and audiomicro, with no results
I cannot find any other recourse at this point other than to ask you to please go to their Facebook pages, and report them for intellectual property violation, as they ARE violating my intellectual property. Please, I ask you, realizing I could fully lose my Facebook over this, but rights only seem to exist in one direction, for the powerful against the weak, so I can’t find anything else to do
Please repeat this at https://www.facebook.com/adrevnet/ and https://www.facebook.com/audiomicro/
Please consider doing whatever you can to fight for content creators’ rights! This is quite an irony for the guy who created the Stop DMCA Abuse page at facebook! I never though it would be me getting nailed, but here I am!
Originally, this was sent as an email to the developers at Positive Grid – Wed, Jun 6, 2018, 4:43 PM
So yes, you are welcome, modelling guitarists everywhere 🙂 No applause, just please subscribe to my youtube channel! https://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=pipelineaudio
*My Hopes for Bias FX 2
Hopefully, you can read this at your leisure, and I know it gets wordy, but I’m trying to keep it as focused as possible as an overall road map to what I’d love to see with the goal of live use in mind. I’ll try to put in a bit of detail between not just a software product, but hardware as well.
It seems to me that one of the absolutely revolutionary hallmark innovations of Positive Grid is that you have an overarching system where a customer can have the exact same sound in many different formats. Desktop VST, desktop standalone, iOS and hardware products can all access the same presets and get the exact same sound regardless of the device and situation they are using it in. Want your studio sound on stage? No problem! (at least for any one individual sound, which is kind of the subject of this whole verbiage). This is absolutely amazing, and really inspires confidence in what is normally a pretty high stress situation.
It is my ultimate goal here to detail a plan that could lead to not just amazing Bias FX 2 software, but be the brains for a potential Bias FX Rack (powered or not), Bias FX pedalboard (a true Helix killer), and a world breaking, paradigm shifting, Bias FX Combo amp.
For the most part, Bias Amp, Bias FX, and Bias Pedal are already perfect for the studio. Some minor quibbles about speeding up the menus, loading, and especially preset management would be nice to deal with, but during a mix or tracking, the Bias family already works extremely well.
My concerns and suggestions here will really be about these products for live use, though likely this will have many secondary benefits for studio use as well.
I’m getting a bit ahead of myself here mentioning hardware, but as you guys have always so seamlessly integrated the hardware and software side, I think it will help to make the most sense of an umbrella paradigm to detail it here in a minor way.
Whether or not you make a hardware version (please do!), these considerations will say a lot about how even the software should work, and give clues as to how customers could implement a live setup themselves with off the shelf hardware.
On the hardware side:
A dual signal path in case users are playing thru guitar amps: One signal, with no cabinet emulation, for feeding to the guitar amp, and another signal, with cabinet emulation on to feed to the PA, or for the modern guitarist, playing thru an FRFR speaker, just the second signal, but with the option always there in case you wanted to monitor through a guitar amp.
Simplest most reliable setup possible, as compact as possible. I already knew that this could be done needing only to plug the power and speaker signal lines in
A capable foot controller, hopefully wireless and rechargeable battery powered as well to really keep the simplicity, and the number of cables and potential problems down, as well as really pushing versatility up. 8 patch/stomp pedals, a tuner/tuner mute pedal, a tap tempo pedal, 2 switches for bank up/down and an expression pedal (or two)
A computer interface, possibly out to a DI to deal with any potential phantom power issues (though that is only a problem with some interfaces).
Properly written drivers so that this thing really could be used JUST as an interface, which means being able to break or mix the amount of the standard path between the input and the output so that if desired, only the processed signal from the DAW would be heard at the outputs. Line 6 has famously blown this on some of their more expensive products, while their cheaper POD series often does it perfectly well
A computer, and the trickiest part, mounting it. If at all possible to be able to avoid plugging anything in, ideally with the computer left in and usable in the same way it was transported. The tablet holder works, but it means setting that up and plugging in power and a USB cable.
Some way to carry all of this, safely and conveniently
Wireless for the guitar, but a way to plug in a cable if need be (could be done with a switching 1/4” jack with the normal going to the wireless and the jack breaking when a regular guitar cable is inserted). Not absolutely critical, but would be nice. Possibly just allowing a space for an existing off the shelf wireless around the G30/G50 size
ideally able to have everything plugged in and in place: power, signal, whatever, barring the very few things needed to interface with the rest of the world
9 volt power terminal for connecting auxiliary devices
On the software side:
Switching as quickly as possible without nasty artifacts and without giant gaps, and boy could those artifacts be nasty!
Software capable of enough routing to handle the dual path and other necessities
Tuner and tuner mute at a glance.
Tap tempo, hopefully with some visual feedback
Auto engage for relevant FX. Once you try this, its hard to go back, and people were really vocal about it when I suggested alternatives.
Ideally, in essence you could create all your favorite mixing chains from your studio recording, and be able to switch between them, that was the be all end all.
Not critical, but highly desirable:
The ability to run any sensible third party VST
Spillover FX, people really loved the automated swells between sounds, and delays ringing on after the patch was switched to another
Ability to use impulse responses anywhere in the chain and on either path.
Financial / Existing Users Considerations:
I would hate to see people who already own existing Bias heads and Bias racks feel like they’ve been obsoleted.
I think that having FX loop functions in a potential Bias FX rack, that allowed the popular 4 cable method to use Head/ Rack for both the amp sound, and then the power section would really keep the value of the older heads. Not to mention that Head/Rack would always give instant access to amp controls (though that could probably be done in a Bias FX Rack as well)
The Achilles heel of almost every product out there. Ideally, switching between patches should be as quick as possible without an audible gap, or any sort of audible glitch between them. Some examples of glitching could be a giant, short spike going well above the volume of either patch, stuck or forced buffer sounds, or massive long term volume buildup from a crossfade.
I see three main, roughly defined paradigms people use for switching right now:
- Preset switching
Being able to build a patch up from scratch if desired, setting any and every parameter as desired, with whatever routing, FX and parameter values desired, storing it and being able to recall it at will.
Advantages: Total flexibility. The ability to consider this patch in isolation without any regard for how these settings could affect other stored patches.
Disadvantages: Presets take a long, often prohibitively long, time to load. The resource cost of loading a preset can have a huge effect on stability.
It is possible (as we have done on our SWS Live switching system), to have each preset stored on a separate track, always running in parallel and simply switch which outputs we hear. However, having other patches ready to go in the background can have a significant CPU cost.
Gig Performer attempts to crossfade between presets, with some pretty extreme reliability issues, and a disturbing volume spike as it crossfades from one patch to another.
[note: the manufacturer has taken issue with this statement. The fact that the manufacturer cares that someone said it should tell you just what a good company this is! I have to stand by that this is what happened to me. I did work back and forth sharing videos or audio clips or something with one of them and with this particular paradigm it seems like the volume spike is unavoidable when switching between similar high gain sounds, but there are many people who will not have a problem with this so take it for what its worth. Also, it should be noted that there were latent plugins in the the chain when these crashes happened, including Amplitube and others that are known to be sketchy in realtime input, however, we were able to get these stable in lbx stripper. However however, there are many people, including the manufacturer who don’t have reliability problems with this software. TL;DR : Gig Performer is excellent software and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it, but you guys know how nitpicky I can get…take all of this for what its worth]
Still, in our scripting, we’ve been able to get decent results crossfading, and then muting at the end of the crossfade to save cpu. There is still a time cost, however, the audience won’t hear a gap.
Generally, taking a predetermined set of FX and then storing different values of their parameters, and recalling them at will.
Advantages: Usually switching FX on and off takes very little time and can potentially be gapless. While a supermassive chain of FX could be potentially daunting to CPU use, it will usually be less resource intensive than multiple patches running in parallel
Disadvantages: You really give up a lot of flexibility without being able to switch FX out totally, though this can be mitigated somewhat with long chains and various routing schemes, though again, at the cost of higher resource use compared to a single preset of each patch setup. Glitches. Turning on and off FX, switching routing and even parameter value changes can be extremely glitchy, though they don’t have to be.
- Cached banks
Having presets loaded into memory, or some other scheme, without actually running them in parallel (except perhaps for a crossfade between them), with only the active patch using any significant CPU. ReValver does this absolutely amazingly well in Gig Mode, though it can glitch a bit.
Advantages: This can be mind numbingly fast in switching time. Can be extremely low CPU use. Gives all the flexibility of presets, without incurring many of the issues of preset switching. Create the exact chain you want, and switch between them at will.
Disadvantages: Can still glitch if you aren’t careful. Like the other systems, buffering latent plugins (like Helix and Amplitube) can cause glitches and even stability issues. The number of patches able to be used in this way can be limited, for instance, ReValver limits this to 8 patches. I propose though, that you could switch banks and upon the first patch you press, the new bank would be loaded. Doing this between songs, for example, shouldn’t be much of an issue, and optimization could of course happen to limit the time bank loading takes
I would propose that Bias FX 2 looked into cached switching if possible. Of course, this does not preclude it from preset switching (and optional crossfades between presets would be very, very cool), or, with a few changes detailed later on below, snapshot switching. By externally controlling Bias FX right now, as in our LBX Stripper script, you can do very comprehensive snapshot switching, though some functions are limited or absent.
Additional DSP Models
Again, keep in mind, and perhaps I didn’t state this strongly enough, but a lot of the goal of this paper is for a completely self contained BiasFX, which would be plenty powerful on its own, though third party VST support inside it would be absolutely wonderful, I don’t think this would translate to iOS very well, so any functions it critically needs, would have to be part of the Bias FX system. Though again, third party VST hosting, especially in a combo amp, rack or pedalboard would be most welcome indeed!
I think Bias FX would benefit greatly (and maybe this could actually be two or more new families in the Bias Pedal system), from the following new types of FX blocks:
Multiband Compressor / Dynamic EQ – What’s a constant topic on the forums and TGP? Low end and mud issues. Someone gets their sound perfect on one set of speakers, but whatever they plug into at the gig woofs out on them, especially during palm mutes. The soundman goes ballistic, cats are living with dogs, its pandemonium! Even a single active band of multiband compression can make a world of difference here. After some testing, I found that Postive Grid’s own Final Touch works amazingly well for this, so you guys already have the DSP for it! It would have to be no/low latency of course.
Impulse loader anywhere in the chain. Impulse loaders can actually get you out of needing to add several linear FX. People can pop in their cabinets or EQ sounds and reverbs. I’ve had great success with using impulses for acoustic guitar simulation. This also puts certain FX in their correct place between amplifier and cabinet (though an FX loop between preamp and power amp might make some purists even happier). In addition, this could be a huge help for the dual path system, so you could easily chose which output gets the cabinet impulse for the PA system
FX Loop(s) – Starting from the Line 6 HD500 and especially well implemented in the Helix, a software movable, software switchable FX loop can be really handy for interfacing with the outside world. This can also help with the dual path issue
Harmonizer – This is a biggie, and can be quite difficult to implement, but it is one of those things that really is on the spec sheet checkbox that people quite often look for. Doing it right is even trickier. Often companies will place these after the cab modeller, resulting in some disastrous noises. Ideally, it would go before the amplifier, assuming the amplifier has a true stereo input. This works fine in Bias FX VST, with the original signal going in one side of the amplifier and the harmonized output at 100% wet going into the other amplifier input. With Bias FX’s existing dual signal path system, this could also work on two different amps, but could bring up some issues with the other important dual path situation, one with a cab emulator and one without (though are potentially tons of ways to route around that)
Again, these could be parts of some new pedal families, or parts of existing ones for Bias Pedal.
Some functionality enhancements that I think would greatly extend Bias FX’s capabilities as a live processing system.
Auto engage – This is a huge one. Once you have used it, it is really hard to go back. Moving a pedal turns on the FX block, pulling it back to zero (or some other value) bypasses the FX block. We’ve made various scripts, plugins and threshold switches to really fine tune the control of this function, such as separate and possibly overlapping on and off thresholds, dwell time, and hold times
MIDI Enhancements –
It would be really nice to assign more than one parameter to the same CC or automation in the MIDI/Automation assignment window
Much more comprehensive MIDI control parameters would be nice, such as ranges to toggle things, minimum and maximum values, critical things like polarity invert and maybe even curve types for parameter values (for instance, volume pedal control in many of these types of plugins is not so good)
Values set for on and values set for off for parameters like FX Pedal bypass. The current situation where these parameters are toggled instead can and does often lead to logic errors, leaving the particular FX block in the wrong on/off state
A master MIDI window where all assignments and control info can be viewed, modified and assigned at a glance. While some of this is existing in Bias FX currently, it seems rather divorced from some of the other MIDI and automation assignment windows. Amplitube VST actually does this part pretty well
Basic GUI control functions – Things like fine tune control (which can be really fiddly right now), direct entry of parameter values, return to preset default, return to FX Block default (both of these for both individual parameters and the entire FX block, and really importantly, some way to see the current value of a parameter without changing it (this one can be a nightmare when trying to match two different presets right now)
Wet/Dry and other utilities for all FX blocks – Some of the pedal models have wet/dry controls, some don’t, and many or all of them could certainly benefit from this function. Also many of the dynamic plugins do not have threshold controls, so a way to turn up the input would be nice. Also, some pedals won’t turn down their output past unity, and would often benefit greatly from doing so
Independent Left/Right bypass – At least for the IR block. This could kill the whole dual path issue in one fell swoop. For other FX this would turn your existing Dual Path setup into 4!
Per FX block presets – This would end so much frustration, and really give you the ability to mix and match favorite settings of individual components between presets
Right off the bat, I have to tell a little story about ReValver. Peavey was one of the first companies to come to us about licensing REAPER to run on their products, so we’ve been in pretty good contact with them for a decade or more now. Of course we flogged ReValver when it came out and actually used it on a lot of albums early on. At the time I had no interest in using this sort of thing to play live so I didn’t dive very deep into that side of it. I have spent the last year now going through the various products on the market aimed at using our DAW stuff live, and spent months on scripting and plugins before someone at Peavey told me to look at ReValver’s Gig Mode, which did about 90% of all the scripts and extensions and plugs I’ve been working on do right out of the gate!
So here I was, with a company I’m very familiar with, and a product I’d been using for ten years, and I didn’t know about a feature it had that should have been shouted from every rooftop! It blew my mind.
You guys have a lot of artists out there, a lot of good buzz, and a lot of good press. At the same time, it is extremely hard to find information about using your products to the fullest. I completely understand and would rather have you spend your time developing awesome products than writing manuals, but somehow, some way, actual use information needs to get out there more. In 2006 before I think there was even a youtube, I made some really crappy Getting Started in REAPER videos, which ended up really launching the thing in many ways. You guys have KILLER videos out there. I’d love to see more how to’s about basic and advanced functions
I know I’m not the only one to say it, but the current preset management system can be a pain. Since the menus in general in Bias are extremely sluggish, getting in and out of Tone Cloud can be really frustrating. Much has been said to hopefully enhance the Cloud as well, like search filtering, and an easy way to delete and rename your own Cloud offerings. An Import/Export Preset and Bank function would be really nice from the existing preset menu.
Off the Shelf – I have several working systems which are capable of taking to a gig and setting up very quickly, using regular products (though often heavily modified) from music and computer stores. These set up with a minimal of cables (even less than most “regular” guitar systems), and can include wireless controller pedalboards as well. However, they look (and look they they would feel like, even if they really don’t) like the proverbial tornado through an airplane junkyard. Looking at them, they take up a lot more space than they need, and have several confidence issues with mounting the computer or monitor. Internal cabling is a bit sketchy and it just feels cobbled together
Turnkey – Its quite conceivable that I could have some chasis fabricated and use some off the shelf parts to make a really clean, reliable, confidence inspiring system, using existing, readily available products, and sold as a complete turnkey product. And that this formula could be duplicated by users who wanted to do it themselves in varying degrees. However, I’d so rather not! I look at what I’ve done so far more as a proof of concept and hope that you guys could build this whole setup instead.
Bias FX Rack – Now we’re talking! I realize that much care needs to be taken not to obsolete existing Bias Heads and Bias Racks, and I think that this is very doable with the FX Loop functionality detailed in the last section. This should definitely have separate volume controls for the guitar amp optimized output (no cab) and the PA/FRFR output (with cabinet emulation). Definitely should have comprehensive MIDI control, but aside from the physical MIDI ports, this should already be handled with the MIDI functionality already existing in Bias FX and the MIDI function enhancements mentioned in the last section. The ability to handle a wireless, battery powered MIDI pedalboard would be nice, but at this price point, most of the buyers probably wouldn’t be averse to buying themselves something like the Panda MIDI wireless to put in their own MIDI control pedals. Of course, the proper combination of 1/4” and XLR outs phantom power protection on the XLRs!), and a USB port both for using as an audio interface (with again, the ability to turn off direct monitoring) and for importing and exporting presets, updates and general backup utilities. A 9v output port for powering auxiliary devices.
Bias FX Pedalboard – The Helix killer. Should have similar FX loop(s) and output considerations as Bias FX Rack detailed above, but with a built in pedalboard, including expression pedal(s)
Bias FX Combo – As the two products detailed above, but built into an FRFR speaker. Because of the onboard USB audio interface, this could conceivably be an extremely convenient way to add 3rd party FX using a laptop or tablet
Current Issues in Bias FX:
Though I’d love to see these fixed today, I put them here rather as something to consider going forward to Bias FX 2
FX block Toggle instead of on/off – I understand why toggle can often be the desired behavior, but quite often it isn’t and leads to logic errors. I would love to see actual on/off control values as well.
Some functions, such as amp on/off aren’t in the automation assignments but sometimes can be found in the other MIDI menus
Fine tune control over parameters, along with direct entry and values at a glance – I detailed this more elsewhere so I won’t dwell on it here
Issues with MIDI polling and message overload – Bias FX can respond very poorly, and even crash if it gets too much MIDI info. When polling for current state, asking for too much information from Bias FX can also freeze or dropout the audio flow.
Sluggish menus, and general stickiness and long loading times – I have detailed a little bit about how I think this can be dealt with, based on what I think the cause is, and can give more detail if needed. Right now, even launching Bias FX on a very powerful computer can take what seems a ridiculously long time. Bringing up the Amp replace menu is such a time consuming frustrating experience that I know I often settle for an amp instead of trying different ones, for instance.
Writing too much hash to the DAW’s project file – Bias FX writes more encrypted data to the project file in even one use instance than all the other plugins in a project, plus the project itself do! I have a strong suspicion that this is intrinsically related to the sluggishness above and have some ways to deal with it, which I can detail if desired.
In Summary/ TL;DR
Positive Grid already has some knowledge building MIDI pedals, and amps, and especially, the best sounding DSP on the planet, and most importantly of all, the knowledge to make this all work.
If you don’t build this hardware, but could at least get some of these changes into Bias FX 2, than its still a huge win, as I don’t have to worry about the software side of it anymore. I know you know how horrifying it is to consider all the little things that can go wrong live from some little bug or issue. Its a million times worse when you are using a DAW program as the nerve center, which wasn’t in any way meant to do this live, and connect all sorts of software that all hate each other. It would be so much easier to just run some Bias FX hardware!
Either way, this is a very exciting time for me, its as much fun, and as much stress, as when we were first making REAPER! Its like the whole ride starting up again.
I hope to hear from you guys soon!
Discussing “Bringing the Studio to the Stage”
The idea and desire to bring every bit of processing power, DSP, routing philosophy and switching functionality that we enjoy in the recording studio, to our onstage guitar setups.
for fixing the IDIOTIC problem of moving audio between apps on windows (Say from your DAW to skype, whatnot), there are a lot of things out that work with varying success. I’ll list them here maybe people can give their experiences.
People often mean quite different things when they use the word “clean”. Sometimes its crystal clean like an acoustic, sometimes its warmish and dull with a bit of breakup, sometimes its spanky like a surf guitar that has some breakup when you really hit it. Many times it the sound of some serious high gain tones, but with the guitar’s onboard volume turned down.
When it comes time to get a totally, not distorted, bright, clean tone, no matter how hard you hit the guitar, things can get tricky. Way back in the day, the Marshall JMP-1 seemed magically capable of it, and so it came as no surprise that S_Gear, in VST was also capable of pulling it off.
In a somewhat excited internet rountable discussion about cleans some years ago, Ken McLaren of AcmeBarGig said to try his Redshift pickup replacer or even an impulse to accomplish this. Of course, I had to ask what he was smoking, as obviously this is a dynamic thing, not a tone thing, and impulses were not going to be handling dynamics at all.
But he insisted, and I tried it, and sure enough, for that crystal clean, I have been using impulses ever since!
Over the past year, I had been loading a custom acoustic guitar response in NADIR in front of BiasFX when using it in VST mode, but always bummed that I couldn’t get anywhere near there in Bias FX standalone
The Acoustic Expansion Pack for Bias FX features a few tools get make the most out of an actual acoustic guitar recording or pickup and magically, a few tools to turn your electric guitar into an acoustic! For some reason, very little info about this expansion pack showed up on the net in any search I did, so I could be wrong about a lot of the following:
Acoustic Sim. This FX Block had little trouble taking my EMG 707s or Blackouts, at full volume even, and making them crystal clean!
The Mid and Top controls gave a lot of the characteristics you would expect from an acoustic guitar, and made them stronger or weaker. I tended not to mess with these controls much, keeping them at their minimum volume, when I wanted a strict clean tone, but dialed them up a bit to get an actual acoustic guitar tone.
Volume seemed to be a regular level control, and I’ll leave the debate about nonliniear effects of the various Bias and Bias FX volume knobs for another forum
String Enhance could give you an exciter type of effect, for good or for ill, it was certainly not subtle, you may love it or you may hate it, but its there if you want it.
Now the Body control is where things get really far from the realms of subtlety. This control turns up or down, what I can most easily describe as a mic pointed somewhere along the far edges of the body of an acoustic guitar, but very very close to the body. It was quite realistic. Exceedingly so. However it realistically simulated the sound of a mic in a position I think people mostly wouldn’t like it. Try it for yourself. For me, it was too phasey and “flute-y” sounding and I would just leave it off normally, though strangely, everything I said makes it sound AMAZING on electric bass guitar! I have no idea why, try it. Switching between the body types underneath the picture of the guitar changes the effect that the Body knob controls. If you have the Body knob all the way off, switching these switches seems to do nothing.
Acoustic Image. This FX Block seems very similar to Acoustic Sim, though I just wasn’t able to get as nice a super clean sound, it gave me a few different options of sounding like an acoustic guitar than Acoustic Sim did. I’d really like to see both of these get a bit of work. They are most certainly usable as is, but I think they could be class leaders with a little more tinkering.
Acoustic Preamp – If you are plugging in an actual acoustic guitar, with a pickup, this FX Block will give you the effect you’d expect when plugging into an old Crate Acoustic amp or, paired with the chorus below, something like running a Roland AC60.
Unlike wither of these, the gain control, and to some extent, surprisingly, the Mid control, will give you some unmistakably tube like distortion. This will not at all give you the “hardness” you may expect and possibly even desire, that a transistor acoustic amp will, and the lack of a Magnetic/Piezo selector switch might make that feel like a double insult.
But that’s before you try the treble control! Want the “spank” of a transistor acoustic amp? Turn it up halfway. Want so much exciter that it takes you into Mutt Lange territory? Keep turning it up. And if you think I’m kidding, here it is on a snare!
An EQ, pretty much as you’d expect. It has two sweepable mid bands with a wide enough Q not to get too “flute-y”.
This is a plugin where you really do feel the limitations of the Positive Grid Paradigm of not having the standard plugin control modifiers, like return to unity gain, return to preset default (or presets at all!), fine tune, direct entry, and perhaps the one that makes it most difficult of all, not being able to see the exact parameter values at a glance. These can all make comparing apples to apples, or really dialing in your sound quite a bit harder than it should be, and hopefully will be looked at across the entire Bias line of products.
Unlike most of the Bias FX modulation blocks, this one has a real mix control! This means that you will likely use this as your chorus regardless of what type of sound you are after. If you don’t care about any of the other acoustic features in this pack, you might just want to buy Bias Pedal Modulation instead, which will get you access to that critical wet/dry control (of course, Positive Grid should have a wet/dry control on EVERYTHING, but until that happens…)
As a chorus, this is pretty nice! No Tempo sync options, no delay control, but it will give you the lush, swirly sound that you are probably after in general, without the phasing problems of the stock Bias FX choruses
Reverb is a decent, basic reverb with no real detailed parameters, but will certainly give you the type of reverb sound you would expect from any of the classic (is it ok to call amps from the 1990’s “classic”?) acoustic amps
Here is a video showing turning a dull, regular electric guitar using EMG 707’s thru a DI box, turning into the type of crystal clean sound I will often use in mixes. After that, I show the effect of the Body control on the Acoustic SIM and the different body styles. Note the phase-y flute-y sound once the body control is engaged. You will be surprised how that can turn into a positive come mix time!
If you are using Bias FX as a standalone, and really need crystal clean tones, this pack is a no brainer, especially if you want to use a chorus effect, ever. In addition to those two major functions, the other included parts open up a pretty decent extra tone palette.
If you are on iOS, it costs almost nothing, definitely pick it up! Desktop users may want to take a harder look, but if you can swing it, its hard not to have it.
As an exciter, this pack is actually cheaper than some of the others out there. Give it a chance vs the usual suspects when doing your drum or vocal mixes and see how you feel about it.
If you are using Bias FX inside a DAW and have access to other VST’s, you can likely get the contents of this plugin from other VST’s, the acoustic sim from an impulse loader of other acoustic sim effect, the EQ, chorus and reverb from other effects, and likely those will have direct entry, fine tuning, double click to unity, presets, and all the basic functions missing in the Bias world. Even in this case though, give it a try and see if its worth it for you for the all in one convenience of storing an entire chain in one plugin for your templates!
With Positive Grid teasing us on Instagram about a big announcement coming for iPhone, and what always seemed to me to be a dearth of specific information about just how to do it, I figured I would write a step by step how to guide on setting up Bias FX on iOS.
The goal of this tutorial is to end up with a versatile live setup, under MIDI control.
Due to the sparse development of audio in general on iOS, there are a lot of issues we have to find workarounds for, but I really think we can end up with an extremely portable, yet extremely powerful guitar rig. But please keep in mind, as we hit walls and pitfalls, there are many different ways to skin this cat, and I am showing one possible way to get through this journey.
For this particular example, I have chosen a hardware setup that is readily easily available, and that I have done enough testing on to confirm that it will behave decently.
iOS Device: iPad Air2. This particular device provides more than enough power for my needs, and previously I had used a Mini 2 which is far less powerful, yet still ran everything here. I suppose an iPhone SE would be quite strong enough, if only PG would release Bias FX on iPhone (oh wait?)
MIDI Pedal: Behringer FCB1010. There are tons of other devices out there that will work for this including the iRig Blueboard. For my needs, I wanted a lot more switches, and having the onboard expression pedals is nice. In this case, I converted the FCB1010 to be both wireless and battery powered (more about this here: Building a Wireless, Battery Powered FCB1010). There is one more mod involving the wah which I will detail below, which could be totally avoided if Positive Grid decides to add Auto-Engage to their wahs and other relevant FX blocks (like the whammy pedal for instance)
Interface: Sonoma Wireworks StudioJack Mini. There are many other options here such as the iRig HD2, or Sonoma Wireworks’ other device, the GuitjarJack Stage, which is also a MIDI controller!
Speaker: Alto TS210. This is a basic, very low cost, very light weight FRFR powered speaker, other popular options are the QSC K series and the Yamaha DXR10. You may want to add a DI box to these in order to send also to the PA without worrying about any possible phantom power damage. One thing to consider, if your FRFR has XLR outs, is whether or not their onboard volume controls will affect the level going to the PA. Probably one more argument for a DI box. I detail using this particular speaker into a conveniently mobile setup here: iOS One Wire Setup!
This is a biggie. Last year, LBX, MPL, Daniel Perry, I and quite a few others around the REAPER community and the Positive Grid pages spent a great deal of time creating different schemes between snapshot switching, crossfading, and caching to come up with instant, glitch free switching using a wide variety of VST plugins, DAWs, scripts and other tools. These are all computer based, though some of this research did result in Juce code which has been offered to Positive Grid and could at least in theory be applied to the iOS version of Bias FX. As it sits, for many peoples’ purposes, switching between presets is just too slow for onstage use, and another way will have to be used, which luckily, Positive Grid has provided for us, though it has some caveats.
This is a big problem, and in the way I’m describing it, there will ONLY be an output suitable for FRFR. There is a way to use dual paths in Bias FX by putting a cab on one Amp path and not putting one on the other, but since we are using path switching to deal with the switching time problem, this will not be available to us. A floating Impluse FX block could fix this, as could treating the left and right outputs differently in the global menu, but sadly, these are only wishes for the future and not the reality of today. As an extreme case, you could stick a Mooer RADAR or something on the FRFR output and leave the cabs off the amps, but that would destroy our simplicity. Running another app thru Interapp Audio might possibly help, but this brings up the unreliability factor by orders of magnitude. Much more about the Dual Path Philosophy Here
Unlike a lot of its competitors, Bias FX does not have Auto Engage for its wah FX. Most MIDI pedals out there have no switches under the expression pedal to allow you to switch manually either, so you have to chose between a variety of decent, and not so decent workarounds.
In my case, I drilled a hole under one of the expression pedals and stuck in a momentary action SPST pushbutton switch. The other end was soldered to the switch of pedal #9. This means that I had to give up one of the FCB1010’s switches, but on other MIDI pedalboards, if it has a second CC input, you may be able to use that instead (still auto engage would be much, much cooler!)
Switching is too slow from preset to preset, so switching between dual paths is the way we will go here. Hopefully, in the future Positive Grid will adress this with a snapshot switching scheme or possibly some more options dealing with crossfading or caching.
By path switching, I mean we will insert the splitter FX block which also adds the Mixer FX block, and allows for two amp paths, and then toggle between path 1 and path 2 with a footswitch, allowing an instant switch between clean and distorted sounds. The downsides of this arrangements are, in most cases, not being able to use simultaneous dual amplifier models, and much much worse potentially for a live situation, losing the ability to have a signal with the cabinet ON for the PA system and FRFR speakers and a cabinet OFF signal, for regular guitar amp inputs. This really does need to be addressed, but for this article, we will just assume you are using an FRFR speaker.
The first thing I like to do is figure out roughly how I would like my pedalboard setup. Usually with the FCB 1010, I like to have presets on the bottom row, with stomps on the top, but given the amount of time it takes to switch presets in Bias FX iOS, we’re using path switching instead, so I will be putting the presets on the top row. I also want tap tempo and a dedicated pedal for the tuner. Also, one of the pedals had to be given up for the wah switch as detailed above (please please please, Positive Grid, give us Auto-Engage!).
Word to the wise, while you are setting this up, try not to get super frustrated that documentation for the Positive Grid stuff is EXTREMELY hard to find. My Google Fu is not weak, but a lot of the answers to basic questions will be elusive.
So my basic layout will look like this
Here is a capture from the pedalboard editor screen, yours will look a bit different depending on the editor you use.
In this case, each bank has three presets, which are the first three pedals on the left of the top row, with Bank 1 having presets 1-3 and Bank 2 having presets 5-7. Due to the way Bias FX’s preset to MIDI PC works, numbering it this way makes life a lot easier for me.
The fourth pedal on the top row (pedal 9) is wired to the pushbutton switch that I wired in underneath the first expression pedal. In this way either that fourth pedal or the pushbutton will send, in this case, CC #9 which I will be using to toggle the wah on and off.
The last pedal of the top row, Pedal 10, is set to CC #10, which will call up the tuner in Bias FX.
The bottom row of pedals is set from CC #1 to CC #5 in that order. Pedal 1 controls the Splitter Switch in Bias FX to switch between amplifier paths. Pedal 2, 3, and 4 are meant to control stomps in each preset. You can even set a single pedal to toggle more than one FX block in Bias FX, which will really, really come in handy, and actually gives you some of the benefits you would find were this a snapshot system.
Getting Bias FX to listen to your MIDI pedalboard can be quite tricky.
In my case, using the wireless MIDI setup, I need to use an app in between my pedal and Bias FX called midimttr. Once the MIDI pedal was paired to the iPad in the iOS settings, I set midimttr to look like this
In Bias FX, click settings, then “MIDI Setting”, then switch “Enable MIDI Control” to the on position. Then click “MIDI Channel” and chose “All Channels” or whatever channel you want to listen to.
For this first bank, I would like a clean preset, a distorted rhythm preset, and a heavily effected, distorted lead sound. Given the MIDI control available to us, what I will really be doing, is creating a preset that can switch between all of these things, and simply set each preset into the desired state and save it that way. As you play more and more with each of these, the individual presets will likely evolve to become quite different than the generic master preset, but its a good way to start.
So here are some screenshots of the basic preset I’m setting up here, which will be available on the cloud
In this example, I have a clean sound on the top path, and a distorted sound on the bottom path. The paths are chosen by switching the SPLITTER between CH1 and CH2. In order to set this up, hit the “LIVE VIEW” button at the bottom of Bias FX. Long press the bottom left button of the LIVE VIEW pedalboard, then press “Splitter Channel Select” then chose “Switch Channels” as shown below.
Now to assign MIDI CC #1 to the splitter, hit the back arrow, then click “MIDI Learn”. Either press the pedal you want to use on your MIDI pedalboard (which frustratingly often does not work) or click the “- +” buttons until you get the MIDI CC number you want. Hit the back arrow and test it out!
Next, while the LIVE VIEW is still showing, set up the tap tempo, by long pressing another one of the bottom buttons then click “Tap Tempo”. Assign it to the desired CC# as you did above, by clicking MIDI Learn. In my case, I am using CC #5. Also, as shown in the picture, you may want to enable “Stick on Board” as shown in the picture. I am reasonably sure that this keeps the Live View assigned this way even when you change banks.
Next on the agenda, let’s get the tuner assigned. Its probably now a good time to talk about the ways that Bias FX lets you assign MIDI control. There seem to be three ways:
You would assume that #3 would show you an overview of all the assignments, but you would be wrong. Here is my assignment screen currently
As you can see, some assignments go to what seems to be a global position at the top, and others end up in a per-preset assignment. I have written to Positive Grid a few times to see if there is a way to explicitly chose which ones go where, or if there are any rules to it, but AFAIK I haven’t gotten a response to this yet. Keep in mind that you may have MIDI controls assigned, that do not show up here. Also, a big gotcha shows in that, just like in the desktop version, not all assignable things are actually assignable in all three places. Some things can only be assigned in Live View, some can only be assigned in MIDI Assignment view, etc. This can be very confusing, and should probably, honestly be worked on by Positive Grid!
Back to setting up the tuner. Use method #3 by going to Settings/ MIDI Setting/ MIDI Control Assignments and chose “Add New Control Assignment”. Click “Utility” and chose “Tuner” which will bring up a MIDI CC assignment screen. Here you can attempt to MIDI Learn the CC or just chose the one you want directly.
Next lets get to some stomps! For my lead sound, I would like a delay and a reverb, and I’d really like them to turn on or off at the same time. Let’s take a look at how to do assignment type #2. On the distorted path, chose the delay pedal icon, and when it shows up in zoomed in mode, long press its power button. Either enter the CC manually in the menu that comes up or attempt to MIDI Learn it. Do the same thing with the reverb pedal. Ensure that they are both either in the on state or the off state (though you can use this same technique to countr-toggle FX as well) and give your pedal a press! They should switch in and switch out as a unit, giving you some of the benefits of a snapshot system, or a MUCH faster preset switch, without having to do a major tap dance on your pedalboard!
Again, BE AWARE, that using #2 to do this may result in the assignment not showing up in MIDI Assingment View, but will still work. Again, Positive Grid should really address this.
Now assign the wah. You can use method #1 or #3 for the toggle switch. And yes, it is a toggle, not a directly on or off, which is an issue that can make some serious trouble, and should eventually be addressed by Positive Grid. In our case, it shouldn’t really give you any grief, but Bias FX Desktop, when used in a host DAW, can have serious issues with this paradigm. In my case, I have used the CC# for the pedal, and the switch wired underneath my first expression pedal, which is CC#9.
Get the Wah pedal assigned next, using either method #2 or #3. In my case, I am using CC #27. On this preset, I also have a volume pedal on the clean path, which I have assigned to CC #11
As briefly mentioned earlier, for this first bank, I wanted a clean sound, a distorted sound, and a more effected lead sound. For the clean sound, simply switch to the clean path of the base preset and save it as “Clean”, for instance, to preset 1B of your current bank.
Be aware that the preset system seems to map from PC #0 rather than PC #1, so if you are using PC 1, PC 2, and PC 3 on your pedalboard, you would want to save your three presets to 1B, 1C and 1D.
For the distorted sound, switch to the distorted path and save as “distorted” to preset 1C
For the effected sound, turn on the reverb and delay, and save as to preset 1D.
Congratulations! You now have a pretty versatile, and controllable live sound setup!
The preset this is all based on is available on the cloud as
“LM212-5150 master” under “Aaron Carey”
It would be nice to see a few of these issues dealt with, a workable dual output system (cab off for guitar amp sends, cab on for FRFR/PA system sends), wet/dry controls for relevant FX, a real harmonizer, and of course auto-input, but this is DEFINITELY a workable setup, and now that there’s an iPhone version, its amazing that the brains of it can fit in your pocket!
How to set up GuitarJack Stage for four presets, auto engage wah and a spillover delay inside of REAPER using LBX Stripper, using free plugins.
Another installment of Bringing the Studio to the Stage. This time, were setting up four presets using the LBX Stripper script for REAPER
First download REAPER if you don’t already have it https://www.reaper.fm/download.php
Then, make sure you have LBX Stripper installed. Download it from here: https://github.com/L-B-X/LBXStripper/archive/master.zip
In REAPER, go to Options then “Show REAPER resource path in Explorer/Finder, go to your scripts folder and unzip the contents of the LBX Stripper zipfile
Install ReaPack if you don’t have it already, you can grab some of the custom plugins used in this project from there: https://reapack.com/
If you haven’t used ReaPack before, after installation, go to the Extensions menu, and browse the ReaPack packages for any plugins you need
Plugins you may need if you don’t have them already:
Here are the example project files: https://www.dropbox.com/s/vzik5zi280pc51i/GuitarJack%20Stage.zip?dl=0
After that, just follow along with the video!
Let me know if you have any issues
You may have noticed a theme, (that I myself didn’t notice till various manufacturers and friends at NAMM 2018 pointed it out to me) unifying my posts on social media, various forums and even this website lately:
The idea and desire to bring every bit of processing power, DSP, routing philosophy and switching functionality that we enjoy in the recording studio, to our onstage guitar setups.
The very basics of this system would be your guitar, whatever system would be handling the inputs and outputs and the DSP involved (be it a computer or multiFX pedal or modeling amp or mobile device, even your phone!), some way to control it (likely a pedalboard), and the ways to amplify this for monitoring and get it out to the PA system
Ideally, especially due to the inherent rule of Murphy’s law and the perceived and often justified unreliability of computer systems, I would like to have the simplest, most foolproof setup possible
As wireless as possible would be nice, and I include power wires in this. If it can be battery powered by rechargables, so much the better
Portability is another big factor. You don’t want to be THAT GUY that takes 20 minutes to set up and still sounds like crap. You don’t want to be that guy that every soundman puts on blast to his peers.
The Two Path Philosophy!
Central to this whole endeavour, is the Two Path Philosophy: In short, there will be an onstage monitoring path, in the role traditionally filled by the guitar amplifier, and a Front of House path, where your signal goes to the PA system. Depending on the actual hardware used, these two paths may need drastically different signals, for instance, a traditional guitar amplifier used for monitoring will want a signal without any speaker simulation on it, while the PA system will absolutely require a cabinet sound to be present. This is a HUGE consideration, and one that the Marketing Machine will ignore or lie about time and again.
If you are coming from an audio engineering background, you will doubtlessly be aware of the constant bombardment of snake oil salesmen, scammers and the nonstop attempt of the Marketing Machine to separate you from your money. I have to warn you, that the guitar world is even worse. Its a mix of the willfully ignorant and deliberately deceptive and finding real answers can be an exercise in tilting at windmills. Good luck, you have been warned.
Here are the basic components in some detail, some or most of these may or may not be combined into a single unit, so take this for what its worth
Guitar to Interface
This part could be as simple as a guitar cable to your interface. In my case, I usually have a wireless with the receiver velcro’d to my FRFR speaker, which also has electrical power, the interface and the DI velcro’d or hot glued to it.
The way to get your guitar signal into the DSP system. This will usually be a combination of analog to digital converters, digital to analog converters, some sort of interface topology for your computer or mobile device, like USB or Lightning, and hopefully some monitoring and control facilities, like output volume controls (don’t laugh, a lot of them don’t have this basic feature!).
If you are using a modeling combo or MultiFX pedalboard, this could also include the interface. Some of them also include the switching functionality. Some of them can also be used AS a computer/mobile device interface either instead of or even WITH the unit’s internal DSP. (Pod XT Live comes to mind, it has a MIDI controller built in for footswitching, a real ASIO interface over USB and a lot of internal DSP). Many of these devices have an interface for the computer over USB but their drivers and control software do not truly allow you to replace their internal chain (such as the Line 6 Firehawk and Line 6 Amplifi 150) sadly.
Standard 2 channel computer interfaces
In general (and this could change) most people will be looking at the standard 2 channel computer interface for this.
Here are some specific USB interfaces that are commonly seen for our purposes:
Shown also are the Round Trip Latency numbers at 512, 256, 128 and 64 samples. Yes, some can go lower, but that’s largely academic. A lot of the DSP we will be using has an RT CPU processing time around 2 milliseconds so anything under that could be irrelevant. It all depends on what you are doing with the signal
The Top Tier:
These are the three with really low RTL figures, and generally highest regarded (rightly or wrongly)
RME has long set the standard when it comes to drivers and performance, regardless of how much the Marketing Machine would love to replace them. Usually RME and MOTU are going neck and neck, but unfortunately, MOTU’s USB performance seems to trail far, far behind. This model has XLR outs, MIDI, onboard meters, and a nice fat volume knob, It also has a not so nice, big, fat, 750 dollar price
This model comes highly recommended across reputable sources, though I haven’t tried it personally. It has MIDI, 1/4″ outs on separate jacks, and a big, fat, obvious volume knob. $250
This device’s RTL numbers justify its inclusion to this particular category. I haven’t tried one myself, and the amount of hype surrounding this company, and what sure seems to be Marketing Machine saturation has made me highly skeptical, but the numbers look good. Separate 1/4″ output jacks and a nice, big volume knob. $200
Commonly used models:
|Focusrite Scarlett 2i2/Solo 2nd Generation||46.307||22.609||10.910||6.009|
The ubiquitous Focusrite units really dominate this market. Forever locked in a war with Presonus over this particular chunk of the userbase, Focusrite’s commitment to user support really seems to help tip the scales in their favor. You will likely be able to find Focusrite products wherever you go and there are always deals online for bundles with these products, in case you need to add recording studio considerations to your purchase as well as the guitar stuff we are focused on here. The 2i2 has separate 1/4″ outs, while the Solo has RCA’s. Both have a nice volume knob and a switch to defeat the direct monitoring. $150 for the 212, $100 for the Solo. Where these seem to fall behind is the RTL at 256 samples, they definitely hold their own at 128. Definitely worth adding to the Focusrite offerings here is the 2i4, which brings MIDI I/O and balanced line outs on separate 1/4″ to the table, at $180
Yep, Behringer. The drivers for these two in particular are actually pretty good! I warn you in the strongest terms not to assume the same for other Behringer drivers. Many require you to use ASIO4All instead. Both units have separate 1/4″ outs and volume knobs, with the 204 adding MIDI I/O. While at extreme low latency settings the focusrite drivers are ahead, at 256 samples, the Behringer drivers pull ahead. $60 dollars for the 202 and $80 dollars for the 204
There are tons and tons of other USB interfaces out there, and if one really screams out at me, I’ll be sure to list it
Sonoma Wireworks StudioJack Mini/GuitarJack Stage – These are the gold standard in iOS interfaces at the moment. HEALTHY output levels, pristine sound quality, stable drivers, lightning powered, with actual stereo outputs, and pass through charging. SJM has stereo outs on a single 1/4″ TRS, while the GJS has separate 1/4″ outs. Unlike most of the rest, these units can handle the Dual Path Philosophy on 1/4″, which can be a real life saver. GuitarJack Stage adds switching and realtime parameter control over MIDI to the equation, plus an expression pedal input. StudioJack Mini goes for $150 while GuitjarJack Stage can be found for $300. iOS has a lot lot lot of limitations for our purposes, the Sonoma Wireworks interfaces certainly help as much as they can to get around them. There are other interfaces out there for iOS, but these two come extremely highly recommended. ASIO drivers let these interfaces double as USB computer interfaces for Windows and OSX as well.
IK Multimedia iRig HD2 – These are probably going to be the most common interfaces you’ll see and come at a decent price. The 1/4″ output is mono, though it does have stereo outs on 1/8″. No ASIO drivers, though it does work with extremely long latency with ASIO4All. $100
The “computer” used for processing. Play your guitar thru your interface, interface sends a signal to the computer, the computer modifies your sounds, send it back out through the interface into the speakers for you and your audience to hear.
MultiFX combos and MultiFX pedalboards fall in this category, but for the most part, they are too limited on their own for our purposes here. We’re really looking at two platforms at this time: Desktop/Laptops running Windows and OSX or tablets running iOS.
Although it could be argued that iOS was really first to the party, and that the saturation of iDevices on the market means that apps and hardware would be plentiful and well evolved, in reality the iOS system is far, far behind the laptop offerings. While there is AudioUnits, sort of, there is no VST, or VST type system to route, process and modify audio between applications. InterAppAudio and AudioBus do actually perform some of these functions, but not in as meaningful a way as you would probably expect at this stage in time. Audio apps are not really developed with real world, onstage use in mind, and their lack of market knowledge really shows in many painful ways.
All that said, you might still be perfectly happy with what’s available out there.
Newer iPad models are certainly powerful enough to handle the processing you want to do.
Sadly, though they were so early to the market, Amplitube for iOS is a pathetic shell of its VST or standalone laptop version. You may find Tonestack as a decent approximation though (and it comes with some cool tricks of its own). Bias and BiasFX work almost the same as their standalone laptop versions do (minus the painful exclusion of Impulse Response loaders, though they will load amps made on the laptop with impulses baked in), though these two processes really benefit from the help of other VSTs and DAW’s internal routing to really make a complete package. There are a few IR loaders you can run inside AudioBus or IAA, but I found them to be far too sketchy for reliable use.
Both Tonestack and BiasFX have workarounds, although very limited, that can get them to Two Path outputs. Tonestack has a splitter and you can put a speaker cabinet on one path, while the other path can carry a signal with no speaker cabinet. For BiasFX, you can create one Amp with an IR built in for the PA path and another amp with the cabinet bypassed for the guitar amp signal. Recent versions of BiasAmp 2 may have an issue with this, I’ll keep this updated. The Bias Solutions require that you have Bias Amp desktop installed on your laptop or desktop. All of the Two Path issues require that you have an interface with stereo outs in order to implement the solutions, so keep that in mind.
Tonestack brings auto engage for the wah to the table, and FX ranging from usable to full on VST quality. Bias seems to have the same quality of amps, indistinguishable between the iOS and VST.
MIDI implementation across the iOS apps is not exactly something to be jumping for joy over. Again this really feels like a case of the creators not having to use these things live onstage themselves. While certainly workable, for the most part, these fall far, far short of even a 1990’s multiFX pedal system, which is a sad indictment on humanity indeed.
Personally, my iOS setup has Tonestack as the host app with Bias FX run inside it through IAA, as I just can’t quite get the Tonestack amps to sound the way I’d like
|Name||Switching||IR Loader||Movable Cab||Auto Engage||Harmonizer||3rd Party VST Host|
Front of House System
Line 6 Pod XT Live as interface and pedalboard